Skip to main content

Pizza 51 | Our Story

A gas station on the corner of 51st and Oak

A gas station on the corner of 51st and Oak

Pizza 51 opened on September 15, 2004, in a converted gas station in Brookside. Today, the restaurant continues under new ownership.
Two years in the making

Two years in the making

The transformation of the old gas station began in late 2002. Nearly two years of planning, environmental testing, licensing, and financing led to opening day.
Bigger than a college hangout

Bigger than a college hangout

The original idea was to serve the college crowd near Midtown KC, but neighbors of all ages showed up and kept coming back. Pizza 51 became a fixture of the Brookside neighborhood — the kind of place where regulars and first-timers end up at the same table.
A commitment to Kansas City

A commitment to Kansas City

Pizza 51 has been part of the Brookside neighborhood since 2004, bringing neighbors together over hand-tossed, stone-baked pizza.
Pizza 51 West, 2011–2019

Pizza 51 West, 2011–2019

Pizza 51 West opened in 2011 in a former gas station in Fairway, Kansas, with the same pizza-and-patio format. That location closed in 2019.
Continuing in Olathe

Continuing in Olathe

Pizza 51's newest location opened in downtown Olathe, again in a space with its own history — a former auto garage on South Kansas Avenue. The menu, the hand-tossed stone-baked pizza, and the neighborhood approach remain the same.